EP247: From Quality Measures to Medicare Advantage (Maybe for All) and Price Gouging, With John Gorman, CEO and Chairman of Nightingale Partners
October 17, 2019
247
34:28

EP247: From Quality Measures to Medicare Advantage (Maybe for All) and Price Gouging, With John Gorman, CEO and Chairman of Nightingale Partners

In this health care podcast, I speak with John Gorman, who is a government-sponsored health programs guru. He’s also the founder of a newly minted organization called Nightingale that (spoiler alert) we discuss toward the end of our conversation. I just want to interject right here that I, for one—but I’m sure John would agree—do not believe that Medicare Advantage (MA) is, as is, perfectly terrific and devoid of problems.

There are, of course, well-known issues with coding, the whole exaggerated diagnoses for higher reimbursements thing … then there’s the whole potentially wasteful quotas payments and the restrictive networks of doctors cited issues. We don’t get into these during our conversation, focusing instead on comparing MA to FFS (fee-for-service) Medicare.

From there, we get into advice for independent physicians in rural hospitals and then we wind up at price gouging by nonprofit hospitals. John’s points are insightful as always, and I guarantee he will give you a lot to think about.

You can learn more and connect with John on LinkedIn.

John Gorman is the founder and former executive chairman at Gorman Health Group (GHG). For 22 years he led the development of the industry’s leading consulting practice and several entrepreneurial ventures in government health programs. John’s work focuses on Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, and Accountable Care Act strategy, governance, and social determinants of health. John considers himself a defender and fixer of health insurance coverage, especially Medicare, Medicaid, and subsidized individuals served by health plans. He has strong opinions and relies on evidence and sound policy. Prior to founding GHG in 1996, he was appointed by President Clinton as the first assistant to the director of the Health Care Financing Administration’s (now Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services) Office of Managed Care.

After leaving GHG in July 2018, John founded and currently serves as the CEO and chairman of Nightingale Partners, an organization dedicated to helping payers and providers make an impact on social influences that prevent patients from achieving healthy, happy lives. Nightingale Partners is a qualified Opportunity Zone investment firm focused on social determinants of health.

John continues to speak regularly at about two dozen industry conferences across the country each year and is regularly quoted in the trade press and national media. He serves on the board of directors of Henry Ford Health System’s Health Alliance Plan in his birthplace of Detroit and serves as a senior adviser on Medicare Advantage and Medicaid to Premier Inc., the hospital purchasing cooperative. John serves on the editorial advisory boards of several industry publications, including Bloomberg Government.


01:37 The quality measures being used to assess value.
04:00 “Half of the rating is attributable to the member experience.”
04:29 Are the ways that FFS and Medicare Advantage value-based care measures are weighted legitimate?
07:59 Insurance carrier profitability.
08:33 Medicare for all to Medicare Advantage for all—how John sees this morphing into the future.
11:07 Is insurance profitability at the expense of the rest of the country?
13:47 “A more rigorous antitrust approach to hospital mergers would certainly help.”
15:10 “Get bigger and get more sophisticated in … the value you bring to the table.”
16:49 “There’s always strength in numbers.”
20:35 EP202 with Frazer Buntin.
23:28 “If you’re not adapting, you’re dying in this environment if you’re a hospital.”
24:37 John’s advice to rural hospitals.
27:44 EP219 with Arshad Rahim.
28:27 What Nightingale is and what they do.

You can learn more and connect with John on LinkedIn.

healthcare,health,gorman health group,measures,quality,nightingale partners,medicare,
|

Episode Support Provided By

Special Thanks to Our 2026 Sustaining Monthly Donors

Kimberly Carleson, Dylan Yahn, Benjamin Light, Matt McQuideAnn Kempski, Spencer Allen, Scott TromanhauserMarilyn Bartlett, 
Steven Elkins, Matthew Bunte, and Lori Smith.

Recent Episodes

EP513: Revisiting Cunning Anticompetitive Hospital Contracts, With Brennan Bilberry

EP513: Revisiting Cunning Anticompetitive Hospital Contracts, With Brennan Bilberry

Listen on Your Favorite App If you are a large employer, union funds broker, fiduciary, or anyone responsible for a health plan that spends half of its dollars on hospital care (which most do), or if you have anything to do with policy or enforcement of policy, yeah … listen this week and next week....

EP512: 3 Kinds of Broker/EBC Rent-Seeking Payment Models—A Lawyer’s Perspective, With Doug Aldeen

EP512: 3 Kinds of Broker/EBC Rent-Seeking Payment Models—A Lawyer’s Perspective, With Doug Aldeen

Listen on Your Favorite App I wanted to talk to a lawyer ’cause, yeah, lawyers are the ones that see stuff that falls the whole way down to the level of legal action. But I wanted to find out what are the main categories of things that wind up in legal land when it comes to broker or EBC (employee b...

EP511: The Tension When Clinical Teams Take On Risk for Policymakers and Others Looking to Rustle Up Future Perverse Incentives, With Dr. Siva and Monica Lypson, MD, MHPE
Relentless Health ValueMay 14, 2026
511
29:3727.1 MB

EP511: The Tension When Clinical Teams Take On Risk for Policymakers and Others Looking to Rustle Up Future Perverse Incentives, With Dr. Siva and Monica Lypson, MD, MHPE

Listen on Your Favorite App Last week, we talked Medicare Advantage with Betsy Seals ( EP510 ), and we talked about finding members who a plan can serve well. This makes sense because Medicare Advantage is a capitated program. In other words, Medicare Advantage plans get paid by CMS a per member per...

EP510: The Impact on You of Medicare Advantage Goings-on (2026 Edition), With Betsy Seals
Relentless Health ValueMay 07, 2026
510
35:3032.5 MB

EP510: The Impact on You of Medicare Advantage Goings-on (2026 Edition), With Betsy Seals

Listen on Your Favorite App I came up with at least one way to tell the difference between making a fair profit and profiteering. If someone makes more money when the patients or members they serve are worse off, yeah, call that profiteering. For a full transcript of this episode, click here . If yo...

EP509: The 7.7% Wake-Up Call: A Roadmap to Align Finance Teams With Non-complacent Benefit Design, With Patrick Nelli
Relentless Health ValueApril 30, 2026
509
37:4834.6 MB

EP509: The 7.7% Wake-Up Call: A Roadmap to Align Finance Teams With Non-complacent Benefit Design, With Patrick Nelli

Listen on Your Favorite App Sarah Monroe: Hi. This is Sarah Monroe in Chicago, and I'm a benefits procurement leader. And I'm curious why you think so few executives take proactive bold action in health benefits strategy given the magnitude of opportunity. Stacey: Isn't that a great question? For a ...

EP508: Why Don't More Self-insured CEOs Take Bold Action in Health Benefits Strategy? With Lee Lewis
Relentless Health ValueApril 23, 2026
508
44:0240.31 MB

EP508: Why Don't More Self-insured CEOs Take Bold Action in Health Benefits Strategy? With Lee Lewis

Listen on Your Favorite App This episode is the very first episode that we have done that is an AMA—an Ask Me Anything—and here is our very first question. Sarah Monroe: Hi. This is Sarah Monroe in Chicago, and I'm a benefits procurement leader. And I'm curious why you think so few executives take p...

EP507: 4 Core Concepts to Buy or Deliver the Highest-Value Healthcare—A Review
Relentless Health ValueApril 16, 2026
507
33:5831.09 MB

EP507: 4 Core Concepts to Buy or Deliver the Highest-Value Healthcare—A Review

Listen on Your Favorite App Look, we wonks, meaning you and me, you're listening to this, so I am on to you. But we wonks in the Relentless Tribe, we move like lightning on Relentless Health Value. We tend to cover lots of ground pretty fast. So, sometimes I like to, with great intention, sum up wha...

Listen and Follow

Sponsored by Aventria Health Group
©2026 BD Bridges LLC. All Rights Reserved.