First of all, I just want to start out this pod and really thank everyone listening and for showing up for a show like this one. You do it and you are here because you care about patients/members.
It’s just so easy to feel like we’ll never be able to do enough, and that’s a rough, rough feeling. Please take a moment to truly hear how grateful I am for you being here and for doing all that you do and that you try to do.
For a full transcript of this episode, click here.
Love the show? Please consider signing up for our weekly newsletter. We'll send you an article covering the latest episode with show notes, mentioned links and a transcribed intro. Join the RHV Tribe.
I saw on the interwebs the other day a Marcus Aurelius quote. What he said was, “Be satisfied with even the smallest progress.” And I think this is really important to remember because nobody working in the healthcare industry, especially today, is ever probably gonna get anything close to a perfect solution. So instead, just aim for progress—even the smallest amount—and feel good about that, please.
This show is an important one for anybody either in the business of healthcare delivery or buying healthcare delivery services. It’s an exploration of what works and what doesn’t work and how what works can easily become what doesn’t work in the face of the real world.
This peril of cutting clinical “waste” perilousness all starts with the whole “Hey, let’s make some money, so we gotta scale and be efficient. We gotta do our thing at as low as possible a cost and maybe grow as fast as possible. We gotta keep our investors happy or pay off the debt we got saddled with or pay that giant management fee we’re being charged or compensate the C-suite at the level they’ve grown accustomed to.” So again, the “let’s be efficient and get everything repeatable” has entered the building.
The first point my guest today, Kate Wolin, ScD, makes about all of this—and this is exactly the same point that Rik Renard made in episode 427—efficient to what endgame? Now, it turns out, surveys show, only a small, small percentage of healthcare delivery solution providers are measuring outcomes of pretty much any kind.
So, how do we even know if cutting so-called waste is actually waste at all? I mean, in the absence of any actual measures—here’s a hypothetical for you—someone could look around: “Hey, I see these nurses. They’re all just sitting around chatting with patients and, I don’t know, talking about throw rugs? What is this? An episode of HGTV? Who cares if a patient with diabetic neuropathy has throw rugs in their hallway? Let’s tell these nurses chop-chop, get them on the computer using AI to be efficient, right? Let’s get rid of that clinical waste.”
I just made a point in the most sarcastic way possible, but the bottom line is this: It’s actually really efficient to not engage patients in these ways, right? Patients, they talk slow, they ask questions that seem irrelevant, and they’re time-consuming. It’s very efficient to not build relationships or foster trust or, I don’t know, assess fall risks … but whatever is going on is also going to fail in that model—from a patient outcome standpoint at least.
Here’s a quote from Sergei Polevikov, with some light edits. He wrote on LinkedIn: Primary care is not scalable in the same way as Scrub Daddy or Bombas Socks. That’s something not taught in MBA and CFA programs. Someone should have told Walgreens, CVS, Amazon, and Walmart.
They also probably should tell a whole bunch of point solutions and payers. Also, some health system execs or pharmacy leaders might also want to get that memo.
What I really liked about the conversation with Kate Wolin in this healthcare podcast is that she retains optimism in the face of all of this. She offers advice for how to navigate the balance between mission and margin in a way that’s better for patients and also sustainable financially. She talks about three points:
1. Founders and investors being in alignment and the essential nature of that
2. The importance of having clinical leadership and a team dynamic that enables innovation but in a clinically sound way
3. How you gotta measure what matters and do it in a way that inspires a mission-driven culture
If we’re talking about relevant shows to listen to next after you listen to this one, please do not forget episode 331. This is where Al Lewis teaches us how to evaluate wellness vendors and health solutions, but it also teaches us how to be a good wellness vendor or health solution. Also, do come back and listen to the encore with Jerry Durham next week about front desks and the total care experience. Lots of really bad avoidable things happen if the front desk isn’t considered—and it isn’t often considered. For sure, also listen to the show with Kenny Cole, MD (EP431); that’s a must-listen. Then again, the show with Rik Renard (EP427) came up several times in this episode. The show with Jodilyn Owen (EP421) also gets brought up; that’s a great cautionary tale there to keep in mind for mission-driven entrepreneurs and investors. And then, I also recommend J. Michael Connors, MD. He writes a lot of stuff in a newsletter along these lines.
Last, last, last … Please go to our Web site and subscribe to the weekly email. I am planning on doing a few invite-only sessions for email subscribers. Plus, the weekly email is a really very convenient way to get the episode transcripts and stuff. And if you don’t get it, you’re making your life less efficient. So, go fix that.
Kate Wolin, my guest today, trained as a behavioral epidemiologist and has done research in chronic disease prevention and management. She launched and led a digital health start-up and sold it to Anthem. She’s been in the digital health start-up space largely at the intersection of science and product strategy ever since.
Also mentioned in this episode are Rik Renard; Sergei Polevikov; Walgreens; Amazon; Walmart; Al Lewis; Jerry Durham; Kenny Cole, MD; Jodilyn Owen; J. Michael Connors, MD; Carly Eckert, MD; and Mike Pykosz.
You can learn more by following Dr. Wolin on LinkedIn.
Kate Wolin, ScD, is a behavioral epidemiologist who left academic medicine to launch and lead a digital health start-up, which she bootstrapped to profitability before selling to Anthem. She has since been a C-suite leader, investor, and advisor to digital health start-ups and enterprise organizations on bridging clinical and behavioral science with product strategy and execution. She has been named as a Forbes Healthcare Innovator That You Should Know and a Notable Woman in STEM by Crains. Dr. Wolin is a Fellow of the Society of Behavioral Medicine and the American College of Sports Medicine and teaches entrepreneurship at Kellogg.
06:24 Irrespective of money, what works in clinical care and population healthcare?
09:51 EP361 with Carly Eckert, MD, PhD(c), MPH.
10:26 Why is creating a gathering place and sense of community important in clinical care?
12:46 “Sometimes, we make this about the clinical provider. It always makes me think about the rest of the people in an ecosystem that create trust.”
13:49 EP297 with Jerry Durham.
14:11 Where can things go wrong when we start to think about the margin in respect to the clinical care that works?
19:35 “We’re actually very unspecific in what we’re trying to achieve a lot of times in these digital health programs.”
24:00 “Are you aligned as a founder, as a business with your investors on the pace of growth and what is feasible … ?”
25:30 Why is Dr. Wolin optimistic about achieving growth and still providing value?
28:17 Why is it important to ask why something is being done?
30:39 EP421 with Jodilyn Owen.
34:35 How are people motivated, and how can you use that to reduce turnover?
35:21 Why measuring what matters and communicating that is important.
Recent past interviews:
Click a guest’s name for their latest RHV episode!
Dr Kenny Cole, Barbara Wachsman, Luke Slindee, Julie Selesnick, Rik Renard, AJ Loiacono (Encore! EP379), Nina Lathia, Marshall Allen, Stacey Richter (INBW39), Peter Hayes
[00:00:00] Episode 432, the knife point intersection of margin and mission and the peril of cutting
[00:00:09] clinical and air quotes waste.
[00:00:12] Today I speak with Kate Wollin.
[00:00:22] American Health Care Entrepreneurs and Executives You Want to Know, Talking.
[00:00:29] Relentlessly Seeking Value.
[00:00:31] First of all, I just want to start out this pod and really thank everyone listening
[00:00:35] and for showing up for a show like this one.
[00:00:39] You do it and you are here because you care about patients slash members.
[00:00:45] It's just so easy to feel like we'll never be able to do enough and that's a rough
[00:00:52] rough feeling.
[00:00:53] Please take a moment to truly hear how grateful I am for you being here and for doing
[00:00:58] all that you do and that you try to do.
[00:01:01] I saw on the interwebs the other day a Marcus Aurelius quote what he said was, Be Satisfied
[00:01:07] with even the smallest progress and I think this is really important to remember because
[00:01:11] nobody working in the health care industry especially today is ever probably going to get
[00:01:16] anything close to a perfect solution so instead just aim for progress even the smallest
[00:01:21] amount and feel good about that please.
[00:01:24] This show is an important one for anybody either in the business of health care delivery
[00:01:29] or buying healthcare delivery services.
[00:01:33] It's an exploration of what works and what doesn't work and how what works can easily
[00:01:38] become what doesn't work in the face of the real world.
[00:01:42] This peril of cutting clinical and air quotes waste perilousness all starts with the whole
[00:01:49] hey let's make some money so we got a scale and be efficient.
[00:01:54] We got to do our thing at as low as possible a cost and maybe grow as fast as possible.
[00:01:59] We got to keep our investors happy or pay off our debt we got settled with or pay that
[00:02:04] giant management fee were being charged or compensate the sea suite at the level they've
[00:02:08] grown accustomed to so again the let's be efficient and get everything repeatable has
[00:02:13] entered the building.
[00:02:14] The first point I guess today Kate Wolland makes about all of this and this is exactly
[00:02:18] the same point that Rick Renard made in episode 427.
[00:02:23] Efficient to what end game now it turns out survey show only a small small percentage of
[00:02:29] healthcare delivery solution providers are measuring outcomes of pretty much any kind so
[00:02:34] how do we even know if cutting so called waste is actually waste at all I mean in the
[00:02:40] absence of any actual measures here's a hypothetical for you someone could look around hey I see
[00:02:47] these nurses they're all just sitting around chatting with patients and I don't know
[00:02:52] talking about throw rugs what is this episode of HGTV who cares if a patient with diabetic
[00:02:58] neuropathy has throw rugs in their hallway let's tell these nurses chop chop get them on
[00:03:04] the computer using AI to be efficient right like let's get rid of that clinical waste
[00:03:09] I just made a point in the most sarcastic way possible but the bottom line is this it's
[00:03:13] actually really efficient to not engage patients in these ways right patients they talk slow
[00:03:18] they ask questions that seem irrelevant and their time consuming it's very efficient
[00:03:22] to not build relationships or foster trust or I don't know assess full risks but whatever
[00:03:27] is going on is also going to fail in that model from a patient outcomes standpoint at least
[00:03:33] I'm an quote Sergei Pilevakov right now with some light edits he wrote on LinkedIn
[00:03:38] primary care is not scalable in the same way as scrub daddy or bomba socks that's something
[00:03:44] not taught in MBA and CFA programs someone should have told Walgreens CVS Amazon and Walmart
[00:03:50] they also probably should tell a whole bunch of point solutions and payers also somehow
[00:03:55] system exacts or pharmacy leaders might also want to get that memo what I really liked about
[00:04:01] the conversation with Kate Wollins today is that she retains optimism in the face of all
[00:04:06] of this she offers advice for how to navigate the balance between mission and margin in a way
[00:04:11] that's better for patients and also sustainable financially she talks about three points first
[00:04:17] she talks about founders and investors being in alignment and the essential nature of that number
[00:04:22] two the importance of having clinical leadership and a team dynamic that enables innovation but
[00:04:28] in a clinically sound way and number three she talks about how you got a measure what matters
[00:04:33] and do it in a way that inspires a mission driven culture if we're talking about relevant
[00:04:38] shows to listen to next after you listen to this one please do not forget episode three three one
[00:04:43] this is where al Lewis teaches us how to evaluate wellness vendors and health solutions
[00:04:49] but it also teaches us how to be a good wellness vendor or health solution again that's episode
[00:04:54] three three one also do come back and listen to the encore with Jerry Durham next week about
[00:04:59] front desk and the total care experience lots of really bad avoidable things happen if the front
[00:05:05] desk isn't considered and it isn't often considered for sure also listen to the show with Dr. Kenny
[00:05:11] Cole that's a must listen that was a couple of weeks ago then again the show with Rick Renard came up
[00:05:16] several times in this episode four two seven as I said before the show with Jodel and Owen also gets
[00:05:22] brought up episode four two one that's a great cautionary tale there to keep in mind for mission driven
[00:05:28] entrepreneurs and investors and then may I also recommend J Michael Connors MD he writes a lot of
[00:05:33] stuff in a newsletter along these lines links in the show notes to all of these things last last
[00:05:40] last please go to our website and subscribe to the weekly email I am planning on doing a few invite
[00:05:44] only sessions for email subscribers plus the weekly email is a really very convenient way to get
[00:05:49] the episode transcripts and stuff and if you don't get it you're making your life less efficient so
[00:05:54] go fix that Kate Wolland my guest today trained as a behavioral epitomologist and has done research
[00:06:01] in chronic disease prevention and management she launched and led a digital health startup and sold
[00:06:07] it to Anthem she's been in the digital health startup space largely at the intersection of science
[00:06:13] and product strategy ever since my name is Daisy Richter this podcast is sponsored by a Ventria
[00:06:19] health group Kate Wolland thank you so much for being on Relentless Health by you today
[00:06:23] thank you for having me if we're thinking about what works in healthcare and then how sometimes
[00:06:30] that might devolve when we start trying to make money at the same time the whole canundrum of
[00:06:38] mission margin maybe we start here if we're just thinking about what works your respective of money
[00:06:45] maybe everyone doesn't know but as someone who spent a lot of her career living and breathing
[00:06:50] journals and articles and PubMed there's a lot of information out there about things that work
[00:06:57] in clinical care in population health care things that have been around for decades in some cases
[00:07:04] the challenge is that many of those things are human capital intensive to plan to train to act
[00:07:11] the Q and to maintain those programs that get tested in clinical trials that get published in
[00:07:17] the research base they're built on relationships between people they're built on time of people
[00:07:24] and together they're built on resources being deployed and the unfortunate thing and one of the
[00:07:30] reasons that I ended up having my as good at the death moments about academic research is those
[00:07:36] things are sometimes difficult to get paid for or difficult to scale so give me some examples you
[00:07:43] said that there is a lot of information about what works relative to clinical care relative to
[00:07:47] population health and we've talked about this ending number of times on the podcast that it is
[00:07:53] at its core at its seed about relationships it's about trust it's about spending time together
[00:07:59] because you got to spend time if you're going to have relationships and trust but what are some
[00:08:03] maybe case studies of things that you have seen which inarguably work so these are things where
[00:08:09] we're deploying people into the community to meet people where they are and that's a phrase that
[00:08:14] we talk about using technology to personalize and hyper personalized to an end of one we've been
[00:08:21] doing that for decades by putting someone in the community and having a conversation with them
[00:08:28] having a conversation around the behaviors that they might be undertaking to take care of themselves
[00:08:34] the barbershop or beauty salon is a great place to have that conversation because you're talking
[00:08:40] about someone who is engaging in to use a modern tape phrase and active self-care and so to have
[00:08:46] a conversation about other things that they do to care for themselves in that moment is meeting
[00:08:52] someone where they are similarly a laundromat is an active care for yourself or your family
[00:08:58] and so to have a conversation about the things that you do as a family caregiver in that moment
[00:09:04] there are examples of that being an effective way to engage people they're places that people go
[00:09:10] regularly right so one of the challenges that we often have in health care is how do we keep
[00:09:16] people engaged and when you're meeting people in a place that they go on a regular basis
[00:09:21] churches are another example of that you're able to have an ongoing dialogue and an ongoing
[00:09:27] relationship because you're leveraging a place in a space where that happens naturally
[00:09:32] and so you're able then to engage people in ongoing conversations around supporting
[00:09:37] preventive health behaviors and behavior change those have been effective ways to do that by using
[00:09:44] relationships of trust to your point that exist and building on them in the places that people
[00:09:50] already are. And Dr. Carly Eckert did talk a bunch about this in the podcast as have others
[00:09:57] just this idea that you know sometimes we talk about access right but if you start thinking about
[00:10:02] just cranking patients through a throughput machine you might have access but you don't actually
[00:10:09] have engagement and therefore it would be questionable whether health outcomes actually improve
[00:10:15] is someone actually going to take their blood pressure medication as prescribed if they don't trust
[00:10:21] that prescription was given from a place of wholeheartedness. Absolutely, I live in Chicago so
[00:10:28] I heard about Oak Street in the very early days of them building that business and one of the things
[00:10:33] that really stood out to me is quite different was the idea of building your facility to not look
[00:10:39] like a doctor's office right but to look like a place that the community would want to come and spend
[00:10:46] time in older adult who is experiencing loneliness their community that sense of loss of community
[00:10:53] and loss of a sense of place as neighborhoods change and to create a gathering place where people
[00:10:59] would want to be then it's that same opportunity to have a conversation with Mrs. Jones about how
[00:11:07] she's feeling if she's like I'm a little uh today right you can say oh when was the last time
[00:11:13] you took your blood pressure and how are the medication working you're building a relationship you're
[00:11:20] building that trust but it also loses some of the paternalism that people sometimes experience in
[00:11:27] the healthcare system it loses some of that shame and we often know that people will tell doctors
[00:11:33] what they think they're supposed to be doing versus what they're actually doing and so if you're
[00:11:38] actually building a relationship by being part of the community and being a place that people want
[00:11:44] to be I think you give yourself the opportunity to actually deliver care in a different way or
[00:11:50] a way that maybe look like how care used to be delivered many decades ago it's not just about
[00:11:56] let's put some technology into a broken place back to the point of you have to have trust social
[00:12:02] determinants is a great example unless a patient really trusts the one that they're talking to
[00:12:09] if they're asked are you hungry? They're not going to answer truthfully so like just getting the
[00:12:15] inaccurate picture of the patient's health and then also having a comfortable circle in that
[00:12:22] that advice is actually taken really requires effort as you said it's very human capital and
[00:12:29] intensive and this also really matters this whole idea of going out into the community because
[00:12:34] as we know sometimes the individuals who have the biggest gaps in care are not the ones who
[00:12:40] are showing up in clinic right if they're showing up in clinic they are in fact engaged at a certain
[00:12:45] levels I think sometimes we make this about the clinical provider it always makes me think about
[00:12:52] the rest of the people in an ecosystem that create trust and a positive experience is thinking
[00:12:59] of it recently someone shared a clip from I think it was like a golden gobs acceptance speech
[00:13:05] and the person thanked that the people who answer the phone at her agent's office because those are
[00:13:11] the people she actually interacts with those are the people that make things happen
[00:13:16] and that recognition that yeah like I might be paying the guy in charge all of this money
[00:13:22] but I recognize that there's all these other people that make or break my experience.
[00:13:27] I think in health care we forget the best experience in my doctor's office maybe the person who's
[00:13:33] working the front desk and may not be my doctor that keeps me coming back and so I think when we
[00:13:39] think about how we build relationships and how we build trust it's not just about what the
[00:13:45] provider is doing but the entire experience. Again there was a podcast with Jerry Durham and it's
[00:13:52] a really great show and this is what the entire show is about just the importance of the front desk
[00:13:58] and the patient experience and not just relative to are you going to get a good review on Google
[00:14:04] or whatever it's actually important for clinical care I encored that show and we'll link to it in
[00:14:10] the show notes. So if we start thinking about all the things we were just talking about having
[00:14:15] community outreach and coaches and buildings and spaces that are welcoming and all the training
[00:14:20] and retraining and paying enough so that we can get quality the quality and level of people
[00:14:26] that are needed so margin is actually a required consideration here in the real world.
[00:14:32] So now let me introduce money into the conversation. The second that we introduce money and add
[00:14:39] margin to the no mission, no margin or in order to have a mission you have to have some margin
[00:14:45] equation. What starts to happen like where does this go wrong? It can go wrong in a number of places.
[00:14:52] The first one that kind of comes to mind is part of that margin is around how do we make this more
[00:14:58] efficient or how do we make it scale and I think a lot of time we have a ton of unarticulated assumptions
[00:15:06] about where we can create efficiency, where tech might be appropriate. Sometimes people actually don't
[00:15:13] do a whole lot of testing and evaluating of what is the one or two things that are key to
[00:15:21] the outcome I'm trying to drive right and maybe embedded within that is are you clear on what
[00:15:26] the outcome you're trying to drive is and then are you actually aligning to that? So okay what I'm
[00:15:33] hearing you say someone thinks to themselves okay well in order to make this profitable I need
[00:15:40] efficiency and we need to be able to scale and maybe one bigots the other right like you can't
[00:15:45] scale unless you have efficiency but then I just think to myself all right I want to make this
[00:15:50] process efficient and I don't really truly understand what might wind up on the cutting room floor
[00:15:56] as being inefficient that actually was integrated in the secret sauce. So I wind up cutting
[00:16:03] stuff exactly that is essential. Exactly because we don't actually pay attention we actually don't
[00:16:08] know what the secret sauce is right how much of this is people how much of this is processed and if
[00:16:14] it's really people are there ways to make the people better and more efficient without sacrificing
[00:16:21] the thing that makes people now doubled in the detail than how that gets implemented but to me
[00:16:27] it's a reflection of you build your business around what you believe is core to achieving the outcomes.
[00:16:34] So I'm going to dig in on that first sack because I am going to assume that you have some
[00:16:40] thoughts relative to how we make sure that actually the most essential ingredients don't wind up
[00:16:46] getting cast off but I thought the other thing that you said was super interesting especially
[00:16:51] in concert with the podcast that I did a couple of weeks ago with Rick Renard in which there was
[00:16:57] this clinical operation survey that he did they found only somewhere between 7 and 16 percent
[00:17:04] actually calculated patient outcomes either prompts patient outcomes or the clinician assessed outcomes
[00:17:14] such a small number so sad but to your point can you even optimize a process and recognize what is
[00:17:24] essential if you kind of haven't figured out what the goal is or what you're even trying to do.
[00:17:31] Oh I think this is such a great question the report that Rick put out was fantastic to me for exactly
[00:17:38] highlighting this idea people are doing things without really being clear on why they're doing them
[00:17:44] or how they're doing them it's actually not a well-documented process I think it makes me laugh as
[00:17:51] laugh cry as a public health person who was like oh my gosh people go to school and they get a whole
[00:17:57] degree in management and so they must be really great managing process and understanding it and we have
[00:18:05] these books that you know are considered bibles of management around measuring what matters
[00:18:11] and I think about Rick's report and I was like if you aren't even clear that you have a process
[00:18:16] and you aren't documenting your process you're certainly not then looking at that process and saying
[00:18:22] what are the key metrics that tell me where the process is breaking down and where it isn't working
[00:18:29] either in terms of efficiency or in delivering outcomes Rick is really shining a light into this
[00:18:35] shadowy corner where we actually a lot of times don't articulate what the measures are along the
[00:18:44] way that indicate the process is working we're not articulating what those intermediate end points are.
[00:18:50] You got to figure out the ultimate key performance indicators KPI's that we're talking about here
[00:18:56] really what are we trying to do ultimately like what does improving patient outcomes mean so like
[00:19:02] if somebody's in our program for one year they should have blah that that happens out of minimum.
[00:19:08] What I love about what you said there Stacey is you articulated a time frame the lot of times
[00:19:14] in digital health we say things like we need to get patients adherent to medication we need patients
[00:19:20] to engage in this self-monitoring behavior and I'm like every day yeah every day every day for
[00:19:27] the rest of their lives yes really like really at no point in their clinical care can we decrease
[00:19:34] that to every other day we're actually very unspecific in what we're trying to achieve a lot of
[00:19:41] times in these digital health programs. I am a fan of the smart goal Kate which is I love a smart
[00:19:49] specific measurable time constraint and doable right so you have to have a smart goal that sits
[00:19:56] at the top of the flywheel but then I what I'm also hearing you say is along the way you need
[00:20:02] leading indicators or signals that the process is in fact working because if you don't and then
[00:20:10] you're continuously improving toward efficiency ultimately what might wind up happening is you're
[00:20:18] like I don't think we need that stuff you cut the step and ultimately your outcomes go down because
[00:20:24] that was something that you're cutting into bone but you don't know it so like this is how margin
[00:20:31] starts encroaching on mission and undermining mission that's the theoretical nut of the whole thing.
[00:20:37] Yeah I applied example of this from my path life we actually do a lot of protocolized things in
[00:20:43] healthcare and like the diabetes prevention program which is the gold standard is this
[00:20:48] many-week program so week one we're going to talk about topic X week two we're going to talk
[00:20:53] about topic Y and people are going to progress through this program there's really not a high level
[00:20:59] personalization people think of these things that like one on one and of one tailoring and in
[00:21:04] many cases they're not one of the things I learned early in in working in this space of these like
[00:21:11] weight management interventions which are fairly protocolized is there's data that if people don't
[00:21:17] lose weight in the first two weeks they are unlikely to achieve the weight loss goal which in most
[00:21:23] of these programs is like three to six percent of your body weight so I'm sitting there thinking okay
[00:21:29] if I'm got someone who has a connected scale and I can actually see that they have lost no weight
[00:21:35] in the first two weeks why would I proceed with the protocol as written that's insane but the
[00:21:41] reality is that's how a lot of these care protocols work okay so now let's introduce confounding
[00:21:48] factors here when you start getting money in place so let's say that I am a venture funded
[00:21:54] digital health rpm remote patient monitoring software I've got a program and I'm getting paid
[00:22:01] PM PM per member per month or maybe I'm getting paid only for patients in the program or at a
[00:22:07] minimum someone is tracking my patient engagement and giving me reports on how many patients are
[00:22:12] engaged there is a really good reason why I'm going to continue the protocol after two weeks even
[00:22:17] though I know it won't work especially if nobody's I mean because measurement let's just say
[00:22:23] has two different sides to it one is the vendor's measurement the digital health company or the
[00:22:29] RPM company are they actually measuring their results but then on the other side does the customer
[00:22:33] even know what to do with the results as measured correct if you are a digital health vendor you've got
[00:22:39] your private equity investors squawking at you to get your ARR up or whatever the acronym of the
[00:22:46] moment is that all have dollar signs in front of them I could very much see that all of a sudden
[00:22:53] the protocol starts to change and not in a way that is going to drive better patient outcomes
[00:22:58] because the metric that we're striving for there is not outcomes it's a growth outcome of the
[00:23:03] business right it's more patients you know in the case of cerebral right the thing they measured
[00:23:08] was scripts that was the metric that they wanted to report on and when that's the thing you're
[00:23:14] measuring and not a clinical outcome that tells you what's important to that business
[00:23:20] and just to remind everybody who might be like what was the cerebral example that was the
[00:23:25] come they got a lot of trouble they're allegedly almost became a pill male for ADHD drugs right lots
[00:23:32] of things happen behind closed doors and lots of speculation has been made about what drove that
[00:23:37] but I think enough times that you start to think there's something to it there's often this sense
[00:23:42] of the business measures and the business growth measures put pressure on the business to do
[00:23:48] things in their product and in their clinical that are not in the best interest of the patient
[00:23:54] outcome it's easy to villainize the finance folks but to me it's a reflection of are you aligned
[00:24:02] at the founder as a business with your investors on the pace of growth and what is feasible and
[00:24:08] what is reasonable and what is required to get there there may be places in health care where
[00:24:15] the growth comes at a slower pace in order to unpack these questions around what is really driving
[00:24:22] the clinical outcome and can we do it in a way that scales faster or is more efficient to drive
[00:24:30] a better margin without sacrificing the clinical outcome I think what I worry about is that conversation
[00:24:38] isn't happening that there may be trade-offs in clinical outcomes that don't have to be made if
[00:24:44] we're willing to grow a little slower so that's actually probably a pretty optimistic picture
[00:24:50] that I just heard you say there because what I'm hearing is scalability and growth is in fact
[00:24:56] possible you just have to do it in a very considered way and in a slow enough way that enables the
[00:25:05] entrepreneur the digital health solution to try something see if it impacts outcomes rework it if
[00:25:12] it does try something else right like that there is in fact a path forward to profitability and
[00:25:18] maybe even to some kind of multiple but you can't do it super fast because then you're probably
[00:25:25] going to make a big mistake that ultimately is going to impact patient care I think I'm optimistic
[00:25:32] that we can achieve growth we can achieve profitability not for every business but for many
[00:25:39] and still deliver outcomes and still deliver value like I do fundamentally believe that or
[00:25:46] I think I would bang my head against the wall one too many times in frustration mic Pico spoke at
[00:25:53] the Kellogg health care conference a couple weeks ago mic is the co-founder and CEO of Oak Street
[00:26:00] health by the way what really stood out to me and the Q&A with some of the Kellogg students
[00:26:05] was this question of like well why didn't you do X to grow faster why didn't you do X to add more
[00:26:10] revenue and what stood out to me as a part of being a leader is what you say no to Mike said yeah we
[00:26:17] looked at a lot of these things but we had to say no because they weren't core to our business and how
[00:26:24] we were going to grow and how we were going to deliver clinical outcomes those are really hard
[00:26:30] things to do in my experience that this the EO when people throw ideas of how you can get more
[00:26:36] revenue more customers is to think about does that come at a cost and do I really understand the
[00:26:42] cost we're talking about here as a cost of clinical outcomes or clinical quality that may be
[00:26:48] sacrificed in the process I'm going to ask you for some pieces of advice both for private equity
[00:26:54] as well as CEOs and I'm going to put words in your mouth here and assume that your first piece of
[00:26:59] advice is going to be exactly what you just said you got a level set together and have alignment
[00:27:06] between the investors and the CEO relative to what does good look like what are we doing here
[00:27:12] and what is the pace of growth which we're going to accept first and foremost this assumes
[00:27:19] mission is measured by an actual KPI by which work is evaluated and secondly that frankly both
[00:27:27] are sophisticated enough in the healthcare industry to understand actually what that means
[00:27:32] because in fact I just had lunch with a doctor recently who had quit a startup because she said
[00:27:40] and this is pretty much a quote she said I just couldn't with the working with a bunch of cowboys
[00:27:45] her term who just were running around breaking things with no clinical knowledge or really understanding
[00:27:53] of what they were doing or the impact that they were having and she said this is really frightening
[00:27:58] and especially so because a lot of their clients were Medicaid absolutely part of what makes
[00:28:02] that a two way street is if you're an investor and you're investing in a digital health company
[00:28:08] that doesn't have someone with a scientific or clinical background in a key position of
[00:28:14] influence like why it's healthcare I think as someone who trained as a population health scientist
[00:28:21] I also get it that it's very hard in these settings to engage with someone who has a clinical
[00:28:28] background and they're like that's not how it's done and the whole point is yes because we're
[00:28:33] trying to do something different you know I've been in that position advising a clinical team
[00:28:38] implementing a new workflow that is traditionally done face-to-face and we're trying to
[00:28:44] bring it virtual and they're like this is how it's done and I was like is it done that way because
[00:28:48] there's a regulatory requirement is it done that way because that's just how it's always been done
[00:28:55] and what are the risks if we were to do it differently there are ways that those things go well
[00:29:01] and there are ways where people really don't feel heard between your clinical scientific folks
[00:29:08] and everyone else and this is one of those things that blows up my inbox and linked in from
[00:29:13] clinicians a lot or scientists a lot is feeling disrespected not heard and I think sometimes like
[00:29:20] I always say to them a great lawyer will say to me these are the 3000 risks in the contract you
[00:29:26] asked me to review because that's their job is to find all the risks that's technically why I'm
[00:29:31] paying them and my job is to say back to them okay help me understand which of these are likely to
[00:29:39] happen and destroy me which of these are highly unlikely to happen but if they do will destroy me
[00:29:46] and which of these are like you know like the impact of this is not that bit right and I think
[00:29:52] there's a lesson to be learned there in how clinical folks interact but the bottom line point
[00:29:58] is the same which is you have to have a clinical or scientific person on the team and that's a
[00:30:03] responsibility of both leadership and in my view investors okay so we've got two pieces of advice
[00:30:10] so far let me recap number one there has to be alignment between private equity or investors maybe
[00:30:15] I would say and the healthcare entrepreneurs themselves and maybe it's just a real also understanding
[00:30:23] that if you want to invest in or build an answer prize mostly for a huge exit like that's the primary
[00:30:32] driver maybe do something else that isn't going to involve grandma's getting suboptimal care as a
[00:30:37] necessary part of the business model and I just do want to do a call back to the show with Jodelyn Owen
[00:30:43] who runs a maternity clinic in a zip code rife with social determinants of how a digital tech maternity
[00:30:51] startup came in with lights flashing on a magic carpet ultimately failed and for all the probably
[00:31:00] reasons that you were just talking about but it wasn't just that digital health entity failed
[00:31:06] it actually diminished the quality of care in the entire community because they disrupted a bunch
[00:31:11] of things in their arrival that had been stable before so like this isn't just the self-inflicted wounds
[00:31:19] but actually we're talking about people here we're talking about patients we're talking about
[00:31:22] communities so what I think I'm doing is I'm understanding your advice in the sense that if
[00:31:28] you're actually going to succeed with the mission margin thing or maybe even just with the margin
[00:31:32] thing you got to do what you said that you have to have alignment between the private equity and
[00:31:36] them and the entrepreneur themselves particularly in the venture space right people say all the time
[00:31:41] that you want the right investor not just a check and I understand you know in a tough funding
[00:31:47] environment particular like the one that we're in can become a harder thing to stomach you just
[00:31:52] capital to survive as a CEO or a founder if you're not having that conversation as part of your
[00:31:59] process to really understand this and to be clear about the assumptions then it's really really
[00:32:06] hard later when you hit the struggle point and you're in a board meeting and saying we didn't
[00:32:13] hit our growth metric and being able to say and here's why but this is something we talked about
[00:32:19] right before you invested that this was a risk if you're not having that conversation before
[00:32:25] the check is written I've seen it with with founders were they're reluctant to give that transparency
[00:32:33] right because they're afraid that the board is not going to reinvest things are going to get
[00:32:38] difficult and and complicated and and so I think it's just is something that can't wait until
[00:32:44] after someone is invested to talk about yeah and I think you know if I was going to just
[00:32:50] throw something out into the universe I really feel like if there's private equity or there's
[00:32:54] venture capitalists out there who's listening to this show and probably if you feel that this way
[00:32:58] you're not listening to the show but all that is cared about is money don't invest in health care
[00:33:05] go level up dry cleaning or something you know what I'm saying this is just there are
[00:33:10] downsides that exceed anybody's wallet here the second piece of advice you offered up is really
[00:33:17] think about the composition of the team and also the team's dynamics make sure that there is
[00:33:22] clinical people experts epitomologists pop health like you've got the right clinical
[00:33:29] and epitomology expertise behavior behavioral health expertise that are on the team but beyond
[00:33:37] ensure that there are efficient and effective ways of working together such that clinical
[00:33:43] feels heard but at the same time there can be forward progress right like there has to be a good
[00:33:49] culture I get it when you're at you know seed stage start up you may not have the need or the
[00:33:55] resources to have a massive clinical team and that's totally fine right like to to have someone
[00:34:01] who is in an advisory role but what drives me absolutely bonkers is a face on the slide
[00:34:08] that you're never talking to you end up with the inclination from those folks to swoop and poop
[00:34:13] and that's not that doesn't work for anyone you have to engage your clinical and scientific people
[00:34:20] in a way that you build trust between the team members so that they can be heard and they're not
[00:34:26] just being asked to rubber stamp things okay we've covered two pieces of advice that you have
[00:34:31] for those with money and those who need money is there a third the third thing I would say
[00:34:36] is we talked a lot in the beginning of the show around how people matter right the front desk person
[00:34:41] matters the clinical staff matters and we're in an era of a lot of burnout and a lot of turnover
[00:34:48] from the workforce yes it's the clinicians but it's also the staff who are cleaning the dialysis
[00:34:54] center are turning over as well and that puts drains on businesses what I would say whether
[00:35:01] your early stage start-up or late-stage business is humans are fundamentally motivated by the mission
[00:35:08] to be in healthcare in so many cases but they are also motivated to be successful in their own
[00:35:14] journey in life they want to know that the work they are doing aligns with the success of the company
[00:35:21] if they're not clear on what success for the company look like they don't see how their work align
[00:35:26] to that success and so to me it does come back this idea of are you measuring what matters
[00:35:32] and to people know how their success contributes to the success of a business for early stage companies
[00:35:40] it's easier to see how your work aligns to those clinical outcome measures but also to the success
[00:35:46] of the business is gross perhaps it's just me and my end-of-one experience but working at a
[00:35:52] fortune five company I did not feel connected to the mission and to be honest I wasn't clear how
[00:35:59] my work connected to the stock price it's really hard to sort of feel like you're moving the healthcare
[00:36:05] business as a business or moving healthcare forward when those things don't connect and the more
[00:36:10] I think you can help people understand what is success for your business or business unit
[00:36:18] and how their work connects to that you have to be clear on what the success looks like to our
[00:36:23] a conversation around measuring what matters it also helps people see how their work connects to
[00:36:28] that well I would reframe that because I can really see exactly the point that you're making so
[00:36:35] I had asked you the original question was what's your advice to ensure that margin doesn't start
[00:36:40] to trump mission and what I'm hearing you say if everybody in an organization understands what
[00:36:46] the goal is and if that goal has a mission focus then you wind up creating a culture which can
[00:36:52] serve you very well downstream but what it also does at every step along the way is now you have
[00:36:58] an entire organization pointed in the right direction and if it starts to go off course margin
[00:37:05] starts to eat mission you have an entire company of people who potentially could be the
[00:37:13] one to raise their hand and say hi like we're going off course yeah and just also be accountable
[00:37:18] to one another and keep each other in check I think what you're saying is super important which is
[00:37:22] probably why they say culture eats strategy for breakfast lunch and dinner whatever that latest
[00:37:27] iteration of that is if what we're trying to do here is hard and we need to stay on the path
[00:37:32] then it would be great to have everybody aligned and accountable to one another yeah Kate
[00:37:37] Wolland is there any place that you would direct people to go if they would like to learn more
[00:37:42] about your work LinkedIn they will find you on LinkedIn Kate Wolland thank you so much for being
[00:37:47] on relentless health by you today thanks D C so let's talk about going over to our website and
[00:37:52] typing your email address in the box to get the weekly email about the show that has come out
[00:37:58] sometimes people don't do that because they have subscribed on iTunes or Spotify and or
[00:38:04] we're friends on LinkedIn what you get in that email is the whole introduction of the show
[00:38:10] transcribed there's also show notes with timestamps just a pricing you of the options that are
[00:38:15] available thanks so much for listening